Blog Network

  • An Affiliate of the Network

    From the Newswire

    Sign up to receive Legal Blog Watch by email
    View a Sample

« Interview: Carolyn Elefant: The Joys of Going Solo | Main | Demands of English Lawyer Mums For Better Hours Changing the Face of Legal Profession in Great Britain »

Judge Grants Motion to Compel Acceptance of Lunch Invitation; No Appeal of Bill Expected

Gaines To those who think humor doesn't see the light of day in a courthouse, we offer this link (PDF, 12KB) to a recent order of the Superior Court of Arizona, Maricopa County in which Judge Pendleton Gaines granted the motion of plaintiff's counsel to compel defendant's counsel to accept a lunch invitation. Apparently, defendant's counsel initially demurred (even though his adversary offered to pick up the tab) on the ground that the invitation was a subterfuge intended to dissuade him from the merits of his client's case.

Judge Gaines would have none it, expressing his confidence in "defendant’s counsel’s ability to withstand Plaintiff’s counsel’s blandishments and to respond sally for sally and barb for barb." To bring matters to a head, Judge Gaines identified alternate venues (consisting of some of the finer restaurants in Phoenix), directed the cost of the meal to be divided pro rata, and suggested that serious discussions only start after counsel had finished their meals (apparently based on the judge's personal experience, shared in a footnote, that empty stomachs are not conducive to collaboration).

While unable to locate statutory authority for his order, Judge Gaines concluded that granting plaintiff's motion was within the inherent powers of the Court.

No word yet on whether defendant's counsel will appeal (hungry parties are invited to file amicus briefs in the event cert is sought).

Thanks to Larry Bodine of the Professional Services Marketing blog for bringing the order to our attention.

Submit Comments to This Post


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Judge Grants Motion to Compel Acceptance of Lunch Invitation; No Appeal of Bill Expected:


The comments to this entry are closed.

Search This Blog



ABA Top 100 Blawg

Subscribe By Email

  • Join the over 30,000 attorneys who receive either daily or bimonthly email updates of the latest posts added to the JD Bliss blog. You can unsubscribe at any time and your information will be kept strictly confidential

    Option #1: Daily Updates

    Enter your email address:

    Option #2: Bimonthly Updates

    Enter you email Address:

Questions? Get Answers!